Tuesday, February 26, 2013

The Search for the Best Vanilla

The Search for the Best Vanilla
Ok Merrie, this is for you! (and me!)

  This all started when my sister-in-law asked what kind of vanilla I used and loved.  I didn't really have an answer other than I haven't ever lived near any gourmet food stores to try different kinds.  But it sure got me thinking.  I usually turn to good old McCormick's Pure Vanilla Extract because Sam's Club carries the big bottle for $6.88 :)  But I do LOVE Vanilla Bean Paste, especially Nielson-Massey.  For those of you who haven't used it, it is just like vanilla extract but it has the little black vanilla bean seeds in it that give that great look and flavor to ice cream and puddings.  A friend of mine brought me some Mexican Vanilla from her vacation so I have tried that too. It is sweeter and has a little different flavor than other vanillas I have tried.
    With that all said, I started doing a little internet research to find out more about this amazing flavoring that is used so, so often.  I want to share with you a little of what I found.  Now, I realized that my search was internet based and therefore may not be the most reliable but I am on a mission to find out just what is the best, and what I may have been missing.
  First things first, vanilla extract should be a dark amber color.  If it is any other color (clear, foggy, milky) know that it is NOT real vanilla but rather synthetic.  There are many countries that vanilla comes from.  A few are: Tahiti, Mexico, Madagascar (are these all countries? I know I am LAME for not knowing!).  Hawaii is the ONLY place in the US that grows and produces their own vanilla extract.  It seems to me that Mexican vanilla is one of the more popular kinds.  There is a big warning out there about Mexican vanilla and it sure caught my attention.  Much of the mexican vanilla (found outside the US) is derived from couramin which is the bean from a Brazilian tonka bean.  While this bean has a very similar taste to vanilla, it is NOT vanilla and the process it goes through actually makes it TOXIC! It has been know to cause liver damage and is also a carcinogen.  Couramin is used extensively in Mexico to produce vanilla.  The US banned couramin laced products back in the 1950's but they still get in.  If you are buying vanilla in Mexico or Mexican vanilla anywhere else, make sure it is clearly labeled "couramin-free".
   Many of the vanilla extracts that find their way into the US are synthetic. The best way to determine quality is based on price.  If they are selling a large bottle for a bargain price it is almost assuredly synthetic.  Another tell-tale sigh is the color. Is the vanilla is foggy, or in anyway NOT dark amber it was probably made through a process using coal tar or from red and brown food coloring.
    Ok, now that I have put all that out there (please don't hate me if I have some faulty info, this is internet research, remember?) I want your opinion.

What is your favorite brand/type of vanilla?

I am excited to find and try some new stuff!  Ok, GO!

Vanilla sites:


  1. I have started making my own. Food Network's Barefoot Contessa (Ina Garten) gave the directions on her show. I have been making vanilla sugar for years using vanilla beans and extract is so easy. Now I just pull a bean out of the extract when I want vanilla bean ice cream. Then I dry the outside pod and put it in my vanilla sugar canister. There are many places on the internet to find vanilla beans in bulk. It does take a few months for the extract to get dark and flavorful but then you can keep it going indefinitely.

  2. I love the Vanilla Bean Paste from Nielson-Massey! I've also been known to use real vanilla beans, and you can get them online for around $1.00 a bean - try http://www.indrivanilla.com/ - I've ordered from them before and they are awesome.

  3. I try to use the pure vanilla extract for everything I make EXCEPT for frosting!!! For frosting the BEST vanilla to use (in my opinion is BAKERS brand imitation vanilla. It makes it soo the frosting isn't soooo strong! Cute blog :)

  4. Love your blog Kadie! I'm going to try the PIzza Factory bread sticks for tonight's dinner:)

    I usually buy my vanilla at Costco, but my sister-in-law brought some delicious Mexican vanilla home for me to try. It is toxin-free, however, it appears almost clear in color so I'm not sure what it's made of. It is super yummy with a robust flavor though. I'm going to try making vanilla extract at home later this year as Christmas gifts. Gotta try it to see if it's really good though.

  5. Hands down Danncy Mexican vanilla, it is the only thing I use. So far I have only found it online.

  6. Hi Dear,

    I like Your Blog Very Much..I see Daily Your Blog ,is A Very Useful For me.

    Vanilla Bean Kings is the best place to buy premium Madagascar gourmet vanilla beans. Buy vanilla beans online We offer a variety of differentgrades and liquid extracts to choose from for all industries.

    Visit Here - https://vanillabeankings.blogspot.com/


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...